Trump Won’t Stop Insisting Sharpie-Doctored Map Is Accurate – New York Magazine

Trump Won’t Stop Insisting Sharpie-Doctored Map Is Accurate

Photo: Tom Brenner/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Though he’s proven himself incapable of working eight-hour days or maintaining a consistent story about why he fired his FBI director, President Trump has shown remarkable focus and dedication when it comes to proving certain minor and irrelevant points. The most famous example is his insistence that he drew the biggest inauguration crowd ever, but his latest fixation is arguably even more pathetic. Though most Americans probably missed Trump’s false claim on Sunday that Alabama was likely to be hit by Hurricane Dorian, he spent the rest of the week highlighting his own embarrassing mistake, touting a map that had clearly been altered with a Sharpie, then repeatedly complaining that the media owes him an apology. By Saturday, following a shameless unsigned statement on Friday from the NOAA supporting Trump’s lie, Trump and his administration had drawn official rebukes from numerous high-profile meteorologists and former government officials.

Here’s a recap of this week’s dumbest saga, which now seems poised to outlast the hurricane itself.

On Sunday morning, Trump included Alabama in a list of states that should be preparing for Hurricane Dorian. Note that he said Alabama would “most likely be hit (much) harder than anticipated”; days later, he says he merely warned that “one model” showed Alabama “would have been hit or grazed” — though the original tweet is still up.

The National Hurricane Center never issued such a forecast. Meteorologists called Trump out on the error immediately, and the Birmingham branch of the National Weather Service confirmed that the president had his facts mixed up. Still, he continued to repeat the error.

“It may get a little piece of a great place — it’s called Alabama, and Alabama could even be in for at least some very strong winds,” Trump said during a FEMA briefing on Sunday. “This just came up, unfortunately. It’s the size of the storm that we’re talking about. So for Alabama, please be careful also.”

Rather than admitting he made a mistake and moving on, Trump insulted ABC News correspondent Jonathan Karl for reporting in a Monday evening broadcast that the National Weather Service had issued a correction, and there was no threat to Alabama.

In an Oval Office briefing on Wednesday, Trump took the next step in his casual dismissal of fact. He unveiled “the original chart” — an older projection model from the National Hurricane Center — in which Alabama appeared to have been tacked onto the forecast in Sharpie. “It was going toward the Gulf, that was what was originally projected,” Trump said. Naturally, he didn’t mention that the weird black bubble was shaped as if to perfectly encompass the Alabama coast, and did not adhere to the form of normal projections.

A White House official told the Washington Post that Trump altered the map himself. “No one else writes like that on a map with a black Sharpie,” the official said.

Shortly after the press conference with the doctored image, Trump tweeted out some evidence to back up his claim: a map from the South Florida Water Management District that was four days old by the time he issued his Sunday warning to Alabama.

Apparently Trump did not see the fine print on the map itself, which reads:

NHC Advisories and County Emergency Management Statements supersede this product. This graphic should complement, not replace, NHC discussions. If anything on this graphic causes confusion, ignore the entire product.

No NHC maps ever projected Dorian to cross into Alabama.

By this point Trump’s Sharpie-doctored map was being widely mocked, and many noted that it’s illegal to present a doctored National Weather Service forecast as the real thing. (The punishment can include a prison sentence of up to 90 days, though Trump certainly won’t face legal consequences.)

Nevertheless, Trump insisted in a pair of Thursday morning tweets that Dorian was originally projected to hit Alabama, displaying his bizarre penchant for drawing out embarrassing controversies way longer than necessary.

About two hours later — after he had retweeted some accurate information from the National Weather Service and attacked actress Debra Messing (you know, the normal presidential routine during a hurricane) — Trump returned to his Alabama obsession.

He revisited the matter on Thursday afternoon, posting a map from last week that showed, at best, a 10 percent chance of tropical-storm-force winds hitting Alabama:

Finally, Trump had an adviser issue a statement saying Trump’s statement on Sunday was based on forecasts that “included the possibility of tropical storm force winds in southeastern Alabama” — a possibility that lasted through Monday morning.

As ABC News notes:

A National Hurricane Center map from Monday morning shows a tiny part of southeastern Alabama having a small, 5 to 10% chance of seeing tropical storm-force winds, or winds of 39 mph or greater. Every state up the East Coast had at least the same slight chance — including New York, Maine and other northeastern states, although Trump never mentioned the slight threat to those.

On Friday morning, Trump complained that the Fake News Media still hasn’t said sorry for its accurate reporting. He also noted that “this nonsense has never happened to another President” — though presumably, that has something to do with Trump being the first president to forge a hurricane forecast map.

Also on Friday morning, the ever-opportunistic Trump campaign confirmed that they see the fight as a base-booster by promoting sales of “official Donald Trump fine-point markers” to capitalize on the controversy and further troll the media. In the afternoon, Trump’s twitter account shared a video which excerpts a very early CNN forecast about the possible path of the Hurricane, in which Alabama is mentioned as in the hurricane’s possible path.

Then on Friday evening, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, a division of the U.S. Department of Commerce, released an unsigned statement rebuking the Birmingham branch of the National Weather Service, which had posted a tweet on Sunday refuting the president’s claim and assuring Alabamians that they were not in danger. The Birmingham office, according to the anonymous NOAA statement, “spoke in absolute terms that were inconsistent with probabilities from the best forecast products available.”

This extremely misleading statement and stunning apparent capitulation prompted outrage from well-respected meteorologists and numerous former leaders at the NOAA, NWS, and National Hurricane Center. All praised the NWS staff at the Birmingham office and most had choice words for whoever was behind the NOAA statement. Some expressed fears that the Trump administration, in service of the president’s vanity, was discrediting government forecasters whose work consistently saves countless American lives.

President Trump made it through most of the day without mentioning Sharpiegate, but then at 4:44 p.m., he claimed on Twitter that he just couldn’t abide the way a single sentence in the New York Times report on the NOAA’s Friday statement had framed his original tweet about Alabama. Indeed, he presented the line — which was part of section reporting that people in Alabama didn’t seem to much care about the controversy — as a smoking gun:

So, when will Trump finally drop this? One senior administration official suggested the media will have to blink first, telling the Post, “as long as it’s in the news, he is not going to drop it.”

And as long as he keeps talking about it, it is likely to remain in the news.

This post has been updated throughout.

Trump Won’t Rest Until We Accept His Sharpie-Doctored Map


donald trump

donald trump

Payments From Air Force Stopovers May Have Kept Trump Turnberry Afloat

By Matt Stieb

The Air Force has spent $11 million at a small airport vital to Trump Turnberry, and has required servicemembers to stay at his Scottish hotel.

vision 2020

vision 2020

Beto O’Rourke Tries on Urgency for Size

By Gabriel Debenedetti

The Texas Democrat has had trouble connecting with voters. Will dire warnings about Trump and a lot more F-bombs bridge the gap?

Interesting trends for Warren as the field of candidates narrows and Democratic voters shift their support

From Sunday’s release of CBS News/YouGov Tracker data:

State by state in vote preference, New Hampshire now sees Warren just slightly up over Biden and Sanders in first-choice preference there, effectively making the primary there a three-way contest. Biden holds onto a small edge over Sanders in first-choice preference in Iowa to go with that still-sizable advantage in South Carolina. Meanwhile, Sanders has a narrow edge over Biden in Nevada.

Biden’s support has largely held and even risen in some places like in Iowa, so the movement toward Warren is not attrition from Biden, but of lower-tier candidates losing supporters who have gone to Warren or, in lesser numbers, to Sanders. … Warren is also under consideration by more Democrats (60%) than Biden is (50%) — suggesting her campaign could have even more room to gain.

Biden does better than Warren in being named the first choice among those currently considering him. For Warren, among those voters not currently picking her as their first choice now, almost half (47%) are nonetheless considering her, so she may have potential room to increase her standing if she can convert those voters.

And more Democrats now believe Warren can defeat Trump:

About three in four of those considering Biden think he probably would beat President Trump, similar to last month, but still a higher number for Biden than for the other top three candidates. But Warren has made strong gains on electability. Among those considering supporting her, the percentage who think she would probably beat Mr. Trump has jumped 16 points since June, from 39% then to 55% now.

Legacy indeed

On the eve of the 18th anniversary of the September 11, 2001 terror attacks, the current FDNY Academy class, set to graduate in two weeks, includes 13 members — 12 men and one woman — whose firefighter fathers were murdered on 9/11, The Post has learned.

The class includes siblings — two sons of one fallen firefighter, and the son and daughter of another hero.

The historic group of at least 16 “legacy” probationary firefighters also includes the son of an NYPD officer killed on 9/11, and the sons of two firefighters who died due to illness linked to their rescue and recovery work at Ground Zero.

This FDNY class has the most “legacy” members since 9/11, though dozens of other sons — and one daughter — have previously joined the force, said spokesman Jim Long.

“Bravery runs in these extraordinary families who have sacrificed so much for our city. I’m proud of the commitment these probies have already demonstrated to the department and look forward to celebrating with them at their graduation,” Fire Commissioner Daniel Nigro told The Post.

No pressure, Lord Barron

President Donald Trump’s campaign manager predicted Saturday that the president and his family will become “a dynasty that will last for decades,” transforming the Republican Party while hewing to conservative values.

Speaking to a convention of Republican Party delegates in Indian Wells, California, Brad Parscale also said the campaign’s goal is to build a national army of 2 million trained volunteers, far beyond the president’s 2016 organization, that in California could help the GOP retake a string of U.S. House seats captured by Democrats last year.

“The Trumps will be a dynasty that will last for decades, propelling the Republican Party into a new party,” he said. “One that will adapt to changing cultures. One must continue to adapt while keeping the conservative values that we believe in.”

Enter Sanford-man

Facing monumental longshot odds in a fractured Republican Party, former South Carolina Gov. Mark Sanford this morning formally announced his bid to challenge President Donald Trump for the White House.

The announcement came during a nationally televised appearance on “Fox News Sunday,” a conservative-leaning news program Trump is known to watch regularly.

The former Charleston congressman has been privately considering a presidential bid since he left office in January and has been publicly exploring its viability for the last 54 days. He is basing his run on a warning that the Republican Party is at an “inflection point” after three years of the Trump presidency, though he is making attention to the ballooning national debt his focal point.

war in afghanistan

war in afghanistan

Trump’s Canceled Meeting With Taliban Was a Failed Attempt to Rush a Peace Deal

By Chas Danner

The Camp David summit was reportedly a last-minute ploy to conclude negotiations and let Trump deliver a grand finale to the war in Afghanistan.

hurricane dorian

hurricane dorian

Trump Won’t Rest Until We Accept His Sharpie-Doctored Hurricane Map

By Matt Stieb, Margaret Hartmann, and Chas Danner

The president suggested on Saturday that we wants to put down the Sharpie, but the media won’t let him.



What the ‘Ahmari-French Debate’ Was Really About

By J. Oliver Conroy

A wonky debate turned into an ugly clash between two visions of conservatism.

higher education

higher education

If Not Snapchat, What? A Guide to Stanford’s Non-Tech Fiefdoms

By Andrew Granato

Stanford is known for producing the tech industry’s elite class. But it’s also a good place for becoming a Master of the Universe in other arenas.

the national interest

the national interest

Eric Trump Encounters Journalism, Is Confused

By Jonathan Chait

How dare the Washington Post offer to speak with sources in our organization?

the top line

the top line

Is There a Recession Coming? Ask Again Later

By Josh Barro

In the latest economic data, there’s fodder for the optimists and the pessimists alike.

More scary news on vaping deaths

Federal health authorities are urging people to stop using electronic smoking products while they investigate the death of a third person from a mysterious vaping illness that researchers say may have affected 450 people around the U.S.

“While the investigation is ongoing, people should consider not using e-cigarette products,” the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said in a news release. The agency also said people should stop buying e-cigarette products off the street or modifying products bought legally.

… A Centers for Disease Control and Prevention spokesman said it is investigating 450 cases in 33 states and one U.S. territory, suggesting the number of reports of cases has more than doubled since the agency updated its investigation last week.



Apple Downplays Enormous iOS Security Hole Found by Google

By Brian Feldman

The company issued a rare response to disclosures Google made last week.



Ted Cruz’s Dishonest Rhetoric About Chicago

By Zak Cheney-Rice

The senator’s attempt to use Chicago to make a point about gun control is the conservative tradition of using the city as a political football.

ThinkProgress is no more

ThinkProgress, the influential news site that rose to prominence in the shadow of the Bush administration and helped define progressivism during the Obama years, is shutting down. 

The outlet, which served as an editorially independent project of the Democratic Party think tank Center for American Progress, will stop current operations on Friday and be converted into a site where CAP scholars can post. Top officials at CAP had been searching for a buyer to take over ThinkProgress, which has run deficits for years, and according to sources there were potentially three serious buyers in the mix recently. But in a statement to staff, Navin Nayak, the executive director of the Center for American Progress Action Fund, said the site was ultimately unable to secure a patron. 

The latest move in the Trump administration’s effort to keep out refugees

The White House is considering a plan that would effectively bar refugees from most parts of the world from resettling in the United States by cutting back the decades-old program that admits tens of thousands of people each year who are fleeing war, persecution and famine, according to current and former administration officials.

In meetings over the past several weeks, one top administration official has proposed zeroing out the program altogether, while leaving the president with the ability to admit refugees in an emergency. Another option that top officials are weighing would cut refugee admissions by half or more, to 10,000 to 15,000 people, but reserve most of those spots for refugees from a few handpicked countries or groups with special status, such as Iraqis and Afghans who work alongside American troops, diplomats and intelligence operatives abroad.

Both options would all but end the United States’ status as one of the leading places accepting refugees from around the world.

vision 2020

vision 2020

Trump Fears Alienating His Base With Gun Reforms. That’s Irrational.

By Eric Levitz

The president backed off background checks for fear of displeasing his core supporters. But he can’t win reelection on their votes alone.

Mayor Pete is using some of his massive fundraising haul to boost his numbers in Iowa

Pete Buttigieg began a TV blitz in Iowa on Friday, starting his first serious paid advertising effort in the first caucus state.

Buttigieg’s new ad, which is running on TV and digital platforms, leans into his biography as a veteran and a mayor. In a 30-second voice-over, the South Bend, Ind., mayor says that in “today’s divided America, we’re at each other’s throats.”

… This week, Buttigieg crisscrossed Iowa to open 20 new field offices, and he has added another 30 on-the-ground staffers, bringing him to more than 100 organizers in the state. The campaign also opened 12 new field offices in New Hampshire this week.

the national circus

the national circus

Frank Rich: Sharpiegate and Trump’s Escalating War on Reality

By Frank Rich

There’s been an uptick in lunacy since recession fears crept onto Trump’s radar — and his delusional claims will only get worse as 2020 approaches.




Amy McGrath Is Wasting Her Chance to Beat Mitch McConnell

By Sarah Jones

The former fighter pilot and Kentucky Democrat wants to take down Mitch McConnell. But she can’t stop getting into her own way.

interesting times

interesting times

Why Boris Johnson’s Awful Start Could Still End in Tory Triumph and Hard Brexit

By Andrew Sullivan

Even with all the questionable moves, he still has a lot of political advantages over his opponents.

the national interest

the national interest

Democrats Need to Plan Right Now for Republican Fiscal Sabotage

By Jonathan Chait

Lock in stimulus for the next recession while Republicans are still interested in stopping recessions.



Everything We Know About Hurricane Dorian

By Chas Danner, Matt Stieb, and Adam K. Raymond

After devastating the Bahamas, the Category 2 storm is moving up the East Coast, pounding the Carolinas with heavy rain and strong winds.

decision 2020

decision 2020

Howard Schultz Reminds Nation He Was Running for President by Dropping Out

By Nikita Richardson

The former Starbucks CEO won’t seek the Independent nomination after all.

the top line

the top line

Walmart’s Gun Decision Is Less Political Than It Looks

By Josh Barro

It’s about perceptions of safety by customers and employees. But it also underlines how much gun-rights activists have overstepped.

Three states are canceling their GOP primaries just to avoid potential embarrassment for Trump

Four states are poised to cancel their 2020 GOP presidential primaries and caucuses, a move that would cut off oxygen to Donald Trump’s long-shot primary challengers.

Republican parties in South Carolina, Nevada, Arizona and Kansas are expected to finalize the cancellations in meetings this weekend, according to three GOP officials who are familiar with the plans.